Tonight’s Play Issue 2 · Early Oct 2026
Costume Quest 2 cover art
Art: Midnight City · from the official Microsoft Store listing

Costume Quest 2

Double Fine Productions · Midnight City

Xbox Series X|SCloud
  • On Game Pass
  • Action, Adventure

About the game

Costume Quest 2 is the sweet sequel to Double Fine’s hit original, Costume Quest, that turned fans of all ages into candy obsessed crusaders. Explore spooky time-traversing landscapes, don adorable new costumes that transform into powerful Hallo-warriors, and collect even Creepier Treat Cards to wield in combat against a legion of hygiene obsessed baddies. Only heroic siblings Wren and Reynold can save Halloween forever!

Read moreShow less

Trick, treat and pick a fight with villainous dental soldiers in Costume Quest 2, the sweet sequel to Double Fine’s hit original, Costume Quest, that turned fans of all ages into candy obsessed crusaders. This inspired RPG adventure includes a range of new features and gameplay improvements to double the amount of mischievous fun. Explore spooky time-traversing landscapes, don adorable new costumes that transform into powerful Hallo-warriors, and collect even Creepier Treat Cards to wield in combat against a legion of hygiene obsessed baddies. Only heroic siblings Wren and Reynold can save Halloween forever!

Description from the publisher’s Microsoft Store listing.

Trailer

Official trailer · Midnight City on YouTube · Watch on YouTube ↗ Trailer & privacyLoads from youtube-nocookie.com only when you press play.

Screenshots

Tap to expand · from the Microsoft Store listing

Story

AI-assisted summary

Costume Quest 2 continues the Halloween adventure of twin siblings Wren and Reynold. After the earlier Grubbins on Ice story leaves them, along with friends Everett and Lucy, stuck among mysterious portals, the group picks a doorway and the player decides which twin to control. They arrive back on Halloween night in their own time, only to see their dentist, Dr. Orel White, leave through a portal into the past. Another doorway then shows a later age in which Halloween is banned and White's dental regime is in charge. You explore those eras with your sibling and allies, gather candy and costumes, and fight turn-based battles as oversized versions of those outfits. New battle options include counters and double attacks, and Creepier Treat Cards can be collected for combat. The goal is to keep White from ending Halloween for good.

Full story (spoilers)

The story begins right after Grubbins on Ice. Everett, Lucy, Wren, and Reynold are stuck in a web of portals and choose one to enter. The player picks Wren or Reynold. On Halloween night they watch their dentist, Dr. Orel White, talk with a time wizard. The wizard sends Orel into the past, then vanishes. A man concealed in a bush opens a different portal, showing a later world where Halloween is illegal and Orel runs a dental dictatorship. That man is Everett grown up, now married to Lucy. The pair send the children into the past to recover a talisman able to open a gate into the monster world, before Orel can take it. Young Orel delays them there. A boy called Monty helps them find the talisman, yet future Orel still steals it. Back in that bleak future they are caught and placed in a school, where they meet Halley, daughter of Everett and Lucy. They have to escape and face Orel. A retinal scanner will open only for Orel, so they return to the past and recruit the younger dentist. During the last fight he rejects what his older self has done and helps bring that version down. Because his younger heart has changed, the children come home to a present in which Dr. White is no longer a villain.

Sources · Wikipedia content is CC BY-SA 4.0 AI-assisted summaryWritten with AI from the sources below and checked claim by claim against them; nothing else is added. Wording is ours; Wikipedia content is CC BY-SA 4.0.

Community

Player reviews

Written by real players. Player reviewsTonight’s Play hasn’t reviewed Costume Quest 2, so this section is all players: ratings, short reviews and comments from signed-in readers. Community guidelines

Details & art: official Microsoft Store listings and press kits; art © the respective publishers. Details & artGame details and art come from each game’s official Microsoft Store listing (cover images are cropped from those official images, or from publisher press kits, with our title overlay; nothing is AI-generated); art © the respective publishers, used for editorial review. Game Pass membership from Microsoft’s public Game Pass catalog, checked Nov 15, 2026. Critic scores appear only where a real aggregate exists; otherwise “Not yet reported”.