Tonight’s Play Issue 2 · Early Oct 2026
Tonight’s pick

What to play tonight

How the 67 reviewed games stack up, plus a quick picker. How the picker worksA quick picker that matches the 67 reviewed games to your night using their real attributes: genre feel, HowLongToBeat times and co-op support.

60-second picker

Pick my game for tonight

Mood
Time available
Players

The ranking

How it’s ranked How it’s rankedOpenCritic Top Critic Average where one exists. Games without an aggregate are listed separately with their single-outlet or Early Access status.

  1. 1

    Hades II

    99% recommend · Play now
    94OpenCritic
  2. 2

    The Séance of Blake Manor

    95% recommend · Play now
    91OpenCritic
  3. 3

    Forza Horizon 6

    99% recommend · Play now
    91OpenCritic
  4. 4

    Hollow Knight: Silksong

    96% recommend · Play now
    91OpenCritic
  5. 5

    Well Dweller

    96% recommend · Play now
    90OpenCritic
  6. 6

    Gears of War: E-Day

    91% recommend · Play now
    88OpenCritic
  7. 7

    Final Fantasy VII Remake Intergrade

    93% recommend · Play now
    87OpenCritic
  8. 8

    Denshattack!

    96% recommend · Play now
    87OpenCritic
  9. 9

    BALL x PIT

    91% recommend · Play now
    86OpenCritic
  10. 10

    Absolum

    97% recommend · Play now
    86OpenCritic
  11. 11

    Thronefall

    100% recommend · Coming Nov 11
    86OpenCritic
  12. 12

    Mixtape

    85% recommend · Play now
    85OpenCritic
  13. 13

    Mouthwashing

    92% recommend · Play now
    84OpenCritic
  14. 14

    Buckshot Roulette

    93% recommend · Play now
    84OpenCritic
  15. 15

    Call of Duty: Black Ops 6

    91% recommend · Play now
    83OpenCritic
  16. 16

    Shape of Dreams

    90% recommend · Play now
    83OpenCritic
  17. 17

    Moonlighter 2: The Endless Vault

    81% recommend · Play now, save often
    83OpenCritic
  18. 18

    Virtua Fighter 5 R.E.V.O. World Stage

    79% recommend · Play now
    83OpenCritic
  19. 19

    Battlefield 6

    89% recommend · Play now
    83OpenCritic
  20. 20

    The Outer Worlds 2

    88% recommend · Play now
    83OpenCritic
  21. 21

    Ninja Gaiden 4

    83% recommend · Play now
    82OpenCritic
  22. 22

    Planet of Lana II

    87% recommend · Play now
    82OpenCritic
  23. 23

    Neon Abyss 2

    64% recommend · Play now
    82OpenCritic
  24. 24

    Keeper

    75% recommend · Play now
    81OpenCritic
  25. 25

    Marvel Cosmic Invasion

    84% recommend · Play now
    81OpenCritic
  26. 26

    Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy

    82% recommend · Play now
    81OpenCritic
  27. 27

    Halo: Campaign Evolved

    83% recommend · Play now
    81OpenCritic
  28. 28

    Ascend to ZERO

    75% recommend · Play now
    81OpenCritic
  29. 29

    Dune: Awakening

    81% recommend · Play now
    80OpenCritic
  30. 30

    Aniimo

    83% recommend · Try it on Game Pass
    80OpenCritic
  31. 31

    Routine

    74% recommend · Play now
    79OpenCritic
  32. 32

    Valor Mortis

    78% recommend · Play now
    79OpenCritic
  33. 33

    The Royal Writ

    67% recommend · Play now
    78OpenCritic
  34. 34

    Blood Dungeon

    79% recommend · Play now
    78OpenCritic
  35. 35

    The Planet Crafter

    75% recommend · Play now
    78OpenCritic
  36. 36

    Hell is Us

    78% recommend · Play now
    78OpenCritic
  37. 37

    Bluey’s Happy Snaps

    80% recommend · Play now
    77OpenCritic
  38. 38

    The Crew Motorfest

    63% recommend · Play now
    77OpenCritic
  39. 39

    Plants vs. Zombies: Replanted

    56% recommend · Play now
    75OpenCritic
  40. 40

    Rematch

    51% recommend · Play now with friends
    74OpenCritic
  41. 41

    Once Human

    54% recommend · Try it on Game Pass
    74OpenCritic
  42. 42

    Forever Ago

    57% recommend · Try it on Game Pass
    73OpenCritic
  43. 43

    High On Life 2

    59% recommend · Play now
    73OpenCritic
  44. 44

    Terrible Lizards

    56% recommend · Try it
    73OpenCritic
  45. 45

    Beast of Reincarnation

    47% recommend · Wait for patches on console
    72OpenCritic
  46. 46

    Mistfall Hunter

    41% recommend · Play with friends
    72OpenCritic
  47. 47

    Quarantine Zone: The Last Check

    50% recommend · Try it
    70OpenCritic
  48. 48

    Kiln

    40% recommend · Try it
    68OpenCritic
No aggregate yet