Tonight’s Play Issue 2 · Early Oct 2026
Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy screenshot
Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy cover art

Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy

Asobo Studio · Focus Entertainment

ReviewedXbox Series X|SPCCloudHandheld
  • On Game Pass (Ultimate, PC Game Pass)
  • Single-player
  • 11½ h main story (HowLongToBeat)
  • Action, Adventure

Art: Focus Entertainment / Asobo Studio (official Xbox Store listing)

Tonight’s Play review · Action adventure · Prequel

Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy review

Asobo’s Crete-set prequel splits critics: some see a stunning, brave shift, others repetitive fights and a punishing second half.

OpenCriticTop Critic Avg · 82% recommend
Player scoreComing soon
Play now

Editorial review · AI-assisted. Player reviews are by real players. AI-assisted reviewWritten with AI help and checked against the critic, performance and accessibility sources linked on this page. How we work · Player reviews are by real players.

Resonance is a prequel set 15 years before the main Plague Tale games, and it launched day one on Game Pass Ultimate and PC Game Pass on Aug 27. You play Sophia on the Minotaur’s island near Crete, with flashbacks to the Minoan past. It adds sword combat with parries and dodges, plus puzzles about reflecting light.

The OpenCritic Top Critic Average is 81, with 82% recommending it, but scores range widely. ZTGD (9/10, Series X) calls it an incredible game from a clearly talented studio, and Destructoid and DualShockers both give it 9/10. PC Gamer (76/100) says it becomes essentially a horror game by its final hours.

The critics who disliked it point to the same problems. IGN (6/10) says its experiments only partly pay off, with simple, repetitive fights and a weaker cast than earlier games. Eurogamer (3/5) objects to the “trauma porn” of its second half and notes there’s no map. Wccftech (7/10) says its roughly 15 hours feel longer, and ZTGD found some chase sequences frustrating.

On Series X, ZTGD played mostly in performance mode with only a few frame drops, but found the 30fps quality mode made combat feel clunky. Fans of the series should play it, while newcomers may want to start with A Plague Tale: Requiem, which is also on Game Pass until Oct 15.

“Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy is an incredible game from a clearly talented studio.”— ZTGD

Hits

  • Gorgeous Minoan setting and mythology
  • Light-reflection puzzles and sword combat add variety
  • Performance mode holds up well on Series X

Misses

  • Fights can be simple and repetitive
  • A grim, heavy second half
  • Frustrating chase sequences
Play it if…

…You loved Innocence or Requiem, or want a cinematic, story-driven adventure.

Deep dive

Time to beat

11½ hMain Story
13½ hMain + Sides
17 hCompletionist

185 / 205 / 55 players polled.

Play now or wait?

Play now

It’s a $59.99 game included with Ultimate and PC Game Pass, so it’s worth trying even if reviews are mixed. Use performance mode on Series X.

Tonight’s Play’s call Play now or wait?Tonight’s Play’s call, based on the sourced reviews and performance reports on this page.

How it runs

Xbox Series X

Played mostly in performance mode with a few frame drops. The quality mode runs at 30fps and made combat feel clunky.

Xbox Series S

Not yet reported

PC

Windows Central never saw it drop below 60fps on an RTX 4060 laptop at 1080p or an RTX 5080 at 4K Ultra with DLSS. PCGamesN hit bugs, T-posing characters and long lag between areas, sometimes needing a restart.

Accessibility

Not yet reported

About the game

Read the publisher’s descriptionHide description

Embark on an original story, prequel to the award-winning games: A Plague Tale. As Sophia, journey to the Minotaur’s Island, outsmart deadly foes, unravel ancient secrets, and confront a mythical creature at the heart of a devastating curse.

Set 15 years before A Plague Tale: Requiem, play as Sophia, a fierce young plunderer, on the run and determined to uncover the secrets of her past. Dive into an original story blending combat, myth and fate with a brand new take in the universe of A Plague Tale.

Sophia’s journey leads to the Minotaur' Island, where she faces deadly trials, navigates treacherous trails, solves puzzles, all while fighting and staying one step ahead of the army chasing her. But the true challenge awaits, as the terrifying creature hidden behind the myth will soon resonate with her…

As you journey deeper into the island’s heart, you’ll confront the truth behind a long-buried curse.

• Followed by many enemies, each drawn to the Island to reclaim a mysterious treasure, you must navigate a treacherous maze. Rely on your agility, tricks and sharp reflexes to outsmart enemies, perfect your parries, and unleash powerful strikes to survive deadly encounters.
• Shift between the Middle Age of Sophia and ancient Minoan times, where echoes of the past shape the battles of the present. Unfold a new story in the universe of A Plague Tale, through the entwined destinies of two heroes linked by fate and the Macula’s mysterious legacy.
• Guided by the knowledge safeguarded in your notebook, follow in your crew’s footsteps to explore a richly detailed world, unravel its secrets, and face deadly trials. Use a stolen Minoan sphere to solve ingenious puzzles by manipulating light - a force woven by Daedalus into the island’s very heart.
• It is said that only a few came back from the island. Lurking in the shadows lives a restless presence. It follows you around, seemingly knowing your every move, as it hunts through the island’s depths. Every step is a risk. Every pause, a potential end. You can’t stop, only hide, outsmart, and push forward.

Can you survive each trial and every step or will you join those who never came back?

For the best experience on PC, using a controller is recommended. Keyboard and mouse are fully supported.

Description from the publisher’s Microsoft Store listing.

Trailer

Official trailer · Focus Entertainment on YouTube · Watch on YouTube ↗ Trailer & privacyLoads from youtube-nocookie.com only when you press play.

Story

AI-assisted summary

Set in 1334, fifteen years before Innocence, this story puts you in control of Sophia, a young smuggler and capable fighter. Since childhood she has carried strange visions: nuns injected her with an unknown substance and made her sketch what she saw, including a Greek warrior standing before huge doors. Her father Alec took her from that place. His lieutenant Faro kept her with the bandits. The visions now point toward Crete, yet a needed key is held in Venice, and an army is already closing in. Beyond that wait an island maze, an old curse, a stolen Minoan sphere that bends light, and a restless presence that hunts anyone who stops. Sophia has to stay ahead of soldiers and rivals who want whatever lies at the center.

Full story (spoilers)

In 1334, smuggler Sophia is connected to the Prima Macula's old history. Nuns injected her at a convent, forcing her to sketch visions of a Greek warrior before huge doors. Her father Alec rescued her, then died on an expedition. Faro, his lieutenant, led the bandits and looked after her. Faro traces the visions to Crete and a key in Venice. A traitor alerts the army; Sophia flees with a mechanical orb, finds the hideout in flames, and escapes with Leni after fighting Faro, who blames her. On Crete the doors lead into Minoan ruins and a labyrinth. Bandits and Venetians plunder while she falls among black tendrils that eat people but fear light. They later devour Leni and the armies as a cloud threatens the sun. Sophia and Faro aim ancient light machines inward until Irene, the traitor, attacks. Sophia kills her; Faro is mortally wounded and volunteers to keep the beam pointed. Ariadne's spirit says King Minos jailed his son Asterion for carrying the Macula, dubbed him the Minotaur, and began bloodsport. Ariadne posed as Theseus and begged for mercy; Minos killed her. Asterion raged after sensing her death once Daedalus disabled the defenses, destroying the civilization. Ariadne asks Sophia to end his pain and cure her arm. Sophia burns his Macula-fused body with the orb, ending the infection on Crete. Faro had marked Alec's body. She leaves a golden crown with him, takes a ship, and sails off. She later tells Amicia, who suspects the nuns were the Order seeking Asterion, then asks about Arnaud. Sophia says that story can wait.

Sources · Wikipedia content is CC BY-SA 4.0 AI-assisted summaryWritten with AI from the sources below and checked claim by claim against them; nothing else is added. Wording is ours; Wikipedia content is CC BY-SA 4.0.

Community

Player reviews

Written by real players. Player reviewsRatings, short reviews and comments from signed-in readers, separate from Tonight’s Play’s editorial review above. Community guidelines

Details & art: official Microsoft Store listings and press kits; art © the respective publishers. Details & artGame details and art come from each game’s official Microsoft Store listing (cover images are cropped from those official images, or from publisher press kits, with our title overlay; nothing is AI-generated); art © the respective publishers, used for editorial review. Game Pass membership from Microsoft’s public Game Pass catalog, checked Nov 15, 2026. Critic scores appear only where a real aggregate exists; otherwise “Not yet reported”.